Government Toxic Liability

House Roll Call Vote 513

1972 Scorecard Vote

Pro-environment vote

No

Votes For

177

Votes Against

171

Not Voting

85

Cyclamate Compensation (HR 13366). The bill permits food growers, manufacturers, and distributors to sue the federal government for losses incurred as a result of the 1969 government ban on cyclamates. The bill sets a bad precedent that could be extended to other toxic substances, making the government liable for damages every time it ordered one of them off the market. Later the same year, Congress approved similar indemnities for pesticide users and manufacturers. This inhibits federal regulation and makes production of untested, potentially dangerous substances necessarily profitable for the manufacturer and hazardous for the consumer and the environment. The Nixon Administration supported the bill. (Passed 177-170; July 24, 1972; “No” is the correct vote.)

Votes

Show
Show
Export data (CSV)
  • Pro-environment vote
  • Anti-environment Vote
  • Missed Vote
  • Excused
  • Not Applicable

Vote Key

Sort by
Alabama
1972 State Scorecard Average

15%

Alaska
1972 State Scorecard Average

58%

Arizona
1972 State Scorecard Average

30%

Arkansas
1972 State Scorecard Average

4%

California
1972 State Scorecard Average

75%

Colorado
1972 State Scorecard Average

52%

Connecticut
1972 State Scorecard Average

97%

Delaware
1972 State Scorecard Average

100%

Florida
1972 State Scorecard Average

30%

Georgia
1972 State Scorecard Average

35%

Hawaii
1972 State Scorecard Average

98%

Idaho
1972 State Scorecard Average

5%

Illinois
1972 State Scorecard Average

81%

Indiana
1972 State Scorecard Average

24%

Iowa
1972 State Scorecard Average

5%

Kansas
1972 State Scorecard Average

25%

Kentucky
1972 State Scorecard Average

20%

Louisiana
1972 State Scorecard Average

21%

Maine
1972 State Scorecard Average

71%

Maryland
1972 State Scorecard Average

83%

Massachusetts
1972 State Scorecard Average

96%

Michigan
1972 State Scorecard Average

54%

Minnesota
1972 State Scorecard Average

47%

Mississippi
1972 State Scorecard Average

24%

Missouri
1972 State Scorecard Average

21%

Montana
1972 State Scorecard Average

2%

Nebraska
1972 State Scorecard Average

4%

Nevada
1972 State Scorecard Average

72%

New Hampshire
1972 State Scorecard Average

88%

New Jersey
1972 State Scorecard Average

78%

New Mexico
1972 State Scorecard Average

94%

New York
1972 State Scorecard Average

63%

North Carolina
1972 State Scorecard Average

47%

North Dakota
1972 State Scorecard Average

0%

Ohio
1972 State Scorecard Average

33%

Oklahoma
1972 State Scorecard Average

3%

Oregon
1972 State Scorecard Average

68%

Pennsylvania
1972 State Scorecard Average

56%

Rhode Island
1972 State Scorecard Average

100%

South Carolina
1972 State Scorecard Average

17%

South Dakota
1972 State Scorecard Average

0%

Tennessee
1972 State Scorecard Average

13%

Texas
1972 State Scorecard Average

33%

Utah
1972 State Scorecard Average

6%

Vermont
1972 State Scorecard Average

100%

Virginia
1972 State Scorecard Average

55%

Washington
1972 State Scorecard Average

72%

West Virginia
1972 State Scorecard Average

0%

Wisconsin
1972 State Scorecard Average

24%

Wyoming
1972 State Scorecard Average

3%